mikhurram wrote:"There is no such thing as right or wrong but thinking make it so"
The benefit of having this discussion is that we can learn and benefit. At times i might be wrong or others. This discussion can enable us to examine our positions and disregard theories taken for granted. A 2% solution of diluted sulphuric acid in water may seem strong but my experiment suggested it the other way around. As an experiment i have applied solution of 2ml sulphuric acid (pure concentrate) in 1 litre of water on my pot bound gardenias and they didn't suffer any side effects. On the contrary the leaves become more greener. Or my more expensive Gardenia Thunbergia i applied in the media first and later transplanted the gardenia after two days taking into account the changes in PH.
Those having doubt as an experiment may try it on gardenia florida available locally for Rs 50 each rather than applying it on more expensive plants. Or it may applied in the pot soil or bed and the plant can transplanted a day later.
We should also take into account the ph of our irrigation water which i believe is alkaline and frequent watering with it would raise the ph level despite making ammendents to the soil. One option would be to use stored rainwater during the current monsoon and 2nd option is using diluting sulphuric acid in water to lower the ph or making amendments to the soil which inevitably would take more time.
below is a link having interesting insights.
http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/loa ... 29810.html
I totally agree that the purpose of this forum is to learn from each other. And it is the debate process that makes the discussion more powerful and convincing. However, I still have serious issues with the above mentioned recipe because we don't have a complete picture of this recipe which seems to cure the yellowing of gardenias. You didn't mention how much of this 1 L solution you add to your pots (amount matters, right). Okay, let me share my concerns:
2 mL of concentrated sulfuric acid (95-98%) in 1 Liter water makes is 0.036 Molar sulfuric acid (0.2%). The calculated pH of this solution is 1.4. This is sufficient to kill
any plant whatsoever, depending upon how much is added to the pots. Acid rains, which significantly damage large trees, usually have a pH of 3 (about 36 times weaker than 0.2% acid). That is the paper work.
Coming to the reality: You don't see any damage and in fact gardenia is happy with this treatment, it means that the starting sulfuric acid is not concentrated. And that's why I asked for a source (whether it is battery acid which is 30% acid or not?) for public's general knowledge.
Thanks,
Farooq